This calculator supports UK/US assumptions only. Choose the applicable market in the calculator or its named UK/US tool. Israeli rules are not implemented.
US Tax Tools · 08
Buy or rent? US math, with MID.
Post-2017 TCJA the standard deduction usually beats itemising. The MID toggle shows exactly when it earns its keep and when it's just folklore.
The property
$
$
%
%
$
Tax position
%
%
The alternative + returns
$
%
%
%
%
Better choice at horizon
Renting wins
$114,666 advantage at year 10
Buy net wealth
$382,450
Rent net wealth
$497,117
Year-1 MID benefit
$0
Renting plus investing wins clearly. Combination of high invest return, modest appreciation, and short-to-medium horizon. MID is unlikely to flip this.
Post-2017 TCJA, MID only helps if itemised deductions (mortgage interest capped at first $750k loan + $10k SALT) exceed the standard deduction. For most middle-income buyers the standard deduction wins; for high-income coastal buyers MID can still meaningfully help. Set the toggle to model both.
Buy or rent, with the tax math honest.
Worth runs MID, SALT cap, AMT exposure, and your equity comp through the housing decision. Join the waitlist.
Frequently asked questions
When does MID actually help?
When mortgage interest + capped SALT exceeds the standard deduction ($29,200 MFJ / $14,600 single in 2025). For a $400k mortgage at 7%, year-1 interest is around $28k, combined with $10k SALT that's $38k, comfortably above the MFJ standard deduction. For smaller loans or lower rates, MID often doesn't beat the standard deduction at all.
What about the SALT cap?
State and Local Tax deductions are capped at $10,000 (TCJA). High-tax states (CA, NY, NJ) have $20k+ in SALT for many homeowners but only $10k counts. That's the main reason MID benefits don't scale linearly with property value in expensive states.
Does this model the AMT?
No, AMT was largely defanged by TCJA (high exemption + phase-out). Very few households trigger AMT post-2018. If your scenario does (extraordinary state taxes plus large ISO exercises), the MID benefit shown is overstated.
We use cookies to keep the site working and, with your consent, to measure what is working across analytics and ad platforms.We use cookies to keep the site working and, with your consent, to measure what is working across analytics and ad platforms. See our Privacy Policy.
Cookie Preferences
Choose which cookies you allow. Necessary cookies cannot be disabled as they are required for the site to function.